Reddit users are divided over whether Roger Clemens is truly the single best pitcher of all time. Some suggest other legendary pitchers as better candidates. Let’s dive into the discussion and see why the sentiment is split.
Summary
- Reddit users debate if Roger Clemens is the ultimate pitcher.
- Several users suggest names like Randy Johnson, Walter Johnson, and Maddux as better options.
- Some dismiss Clemens entirely, listing a range of pitchers they deem superior.
Randy Johnson – A Strong Contender
One user argues, ‘Well to even start, I’d even say I’d take Randy Johnson at least over RC.’ Johnson’s dominance on the mound is a point of contention in the discussion.
Other Legendary Pitchers
Desert_Rush39 lists a lineup of legendary pitchers, including Maddux, Johnson, Carlton, and Ryan, whom they believe outshine Clemens. The debate showcases the depth of pitching talent in baseball history.
Contrarian Opinions
Thisisnotanaccount5 cuts through the debate with a blunt statement, ‘This is a stupid question.’ While some dismiss Clemens, others challenge the premise of the discussion itself.
Reddit’s lively discussion brings to light the varied opinions on who holds the title of the best pitcher of all time. While Clemens has his supporters, he also faces stiff competition from a roster of legendary pitchers. As the debate rages on, one thing is clear: the greats of the game will always spark passionate discussions among fans.