When considering the GOAT QB, should team success matter? Reddit NFL fans weigh in on the discussion and offer fascinating perspectives.
Summary
- Exploring GOAT QB candidates when team success is removed
- Marino, Manning, Brees mentioned for exceptional individual performances
- Debate surrounding statistical achievements versus championship wins
Brady, Montana, Mahomes: Legacy Diminished?
Some argue that without team success as a factor, QBs like Brady, Montana, and Mahomes lose their luster, bringing other contenders to the forefront. The discussion shifts from rings to individual talent, sparking new considerations.
Brees in the Limelight
With team success discounted, Brees emerges as a top contender due to his remarkable statistical achievements. Reddit users highlight his consistency and the impact of team performance on his legacy, reshaping the GOAT conversation.
Marino’s Untouchable Skill
Marino’s exceptional arm talent and groundbreaking performances in an era of tough defenses make a strong case for his GOAT status. Users appreciate his ahead-of-his-time stats, highlighting the relevance of individual prowess in QB greatness.