MLB fans took to Reddit to discuss Jim Edmonds’ legendary catch in 2004.
Summary
- Edmonds’ catch divided fans between admiring his skill and disliking his attitude.
- Some fans changed their opinion of Edmonds after he retired.
- His reputation as a player varied based on personal experiences.
Positive Reactions
“I don’t know if he was one of the best CFs ever, but his highlight reel is second to none, that’s for sure.” – ARoundForEveryone
“I was there!” – nwostar
Negative Reactions
“Edmonds seems like such a douche…could he run a ball down.” – SilverbackMD
“He was one of the most hated players for me until after he retired then massive props.” – froman_og
Mixed Sentiments
“Does Ivan Calderon robbing Alan Trammell count as an equally great catch – even though the bastard totally cheated!” – Agreeable_Code7788
“I fucking knew it was against the reds before I even hit play. He was a fucking reds killer along with Bill Hall and Scott Rolen.” – Calledthewolf
“