The Great NCAA Tournament Size Debate: Fixed Number vs. Percentage of D1 Teams

Should the NCAA Tournament size be a fixed number or a percentage of D1 teams? Reddit users weigh in on this divisive topic.

Summary

  • Proposing a percentage-based approach to determine NCAA Tournament size.
  • Debate between fixed number advocates and percentage supporters.
  • Concerns raised about potential implications on the tournament’s integrity.

Fixed Number Fans

While some argue for keeping the tournament size at 64 teams, others feel a change is unnecessary. One user sarcastically suggests improving to make it into the tournament, while another simply states, “Nah put it back to 64 and leave it alone.”

Percentage Advocates

Supporters of the percentage-based model emphasize adaptability and organic adjustments. However, skepticism exists regarding the necessity of such changes. The idea of overthinking a well-loved event is questioned, with one user dismissing it as “peak off-season shit posting.”

Integrity Concerns

Some users worry about fixing what isn’t broken and point out the tournament’s popularity. Others raise valid questions about the current model’s flaws and the perpetual pursuit of perfection in team selection.