In a recent post on a popular subreddit, a user questioned whether Newcastle United or any mid-table Premier League teams should consider signing James Tavernier, the Rangers star who had an impressive season with 27 goals and assists combined. The post, by ‘OkayDudeChillOut’, pointed out Tavernier’s capabilities as a talented attacking fullback who could contribute significantly to teams outside the top tier of the league. However, the discussion sparked a divided opinion among fans, some praising his potential while others dismissed it based on various parameters, including his age, the league he plays in, and his past performances.
Summary
- The original post highlights the impressive stats of James Tavernier as a potential target for Newcastle or other mid-table teams.
- Responses varied greatly, with some fans enthusiastic about his attacking style, while others pointed out weaknesses and age as concerns.
- Several commenters suggested that Tavernier’s performance in the SPL may not translate effectively to the higher competition of the Premier League.
- The age factor also played a significant role in the discussions surrounding his ability to adapt to the intense pace of the Premier League.
The Case For Tavernier
Starting with the positives, several commenters acknowledged Tavernier’s offensive prowess and his statistics, which show a remarkable ability to contribute to the attack as a fullback. One user pointed out that his stats from the Scottish Premiership (SPL) reflect an impressive average of 20 goals and assists each season. In their view, his skill could definitely fit into teams seeking a proven attacking option, especially for those looking to elevate their roster. As one user stated, ‘He scores about 15 pens every season,’ showcasing his value as a set-piece threat. This user portrayed him as a player who can be an asset on the offensive side of the game, potentially clarifying the lure for teams seeking creative playmakers.
Criticism on Performance in SPL
However, many commenters were skeptical about his abilities against the fiercer competition in the Premier League. Several fans pointed out that excelling in the SPL doesn’t necessarily account for success at a higher level. SirTunnocksTeaCake, a user from the conversation, mentioned, ‘producing in the SPL means nothing compared to the PL.’ This sentiment was echoed by multiple posters who raised concerns regarding how Tavernier might cope when faced with the quickness and creativity of Premier League forwards. Specifically, names like Saka and Son were dropped to underscore the challenges he may experience against elite competition. Although his attacking stats are impressive, many believe that they do not directly correlate to the performances he might exhibit in the Premier.
The Age Factor
Age was another major topic of discussion within the thread. Tavernier, who is over 30, raises eyebrows about his longevity in a demanding league like the Premier League. GrumpyOldFart74 provided a comprehensive history of his career, highlighting that Tavernier faced several lower-division loans before making a name for himself at Rangers. This user questioned how a player coming from a less demanding league and entering the twilight of his career would transition into the fast-paced world of the Premier League. With alternative options like Trippier and Livramento being mentioned regularly, many could not understand why Tavernier would be prioritized, especially when he is almost the same age as the current fullback options at Newcastle.
Fan Sentiment and Future Considerations
The response to Tavernier’s potential move revealed substantial split sentiment among fans. While some were keen and hopeful toward his inclusion in any Premier League squad, many were less enthusiastic. Comments ranged from swathes of skepticism about his defensive capabilities to questioning if the price tag for a player of his profile would be justified. For instance, one user reflected, ‘getting 20 G/A as a fullback in the SPL won’t translate to the EPL’, indicating a cautious yet practical approach to the idea of Tavernier making the switch. Such mixed opinions illustrate a broader sentiment shared by many: while Tavernier has potential, the Premier League might be an arduous challenge for him. As other users pointed out, he might fit better in a team that won’t demand as much or that is more focused on mid-table security than fighting for European spots.
Overall, the conversation surrounding James Tavernier is as multifaceted as they come. The merits of his attacking stats bring excitement for certain supporters, while others underscore the fundamental differences between leagues, heightening the questions of adaptability and fitness. Moving forward, whether a Premier League club takes the plunge remains seen, but it appears that for now, Tavernier will remain a subject of debate fueled by curiosity and skepticism alike.