The Reddit post titled ‘r/NFL ranks starting Quarterbacks’ by user LindyNet sparked quite the conversation among football fans eager to express their opinions on this year’s lineup of signal-callers. In his post, LindyNet invited users to participate in a survey where they could compare pairs of quarterbacks who started games this past season and select who they believed was better. As the call to action unfolded, it quickly became clear that the rankings stirred a blend of excitement and frustration among participants, with the process itself eliciting mixed feelings.
Summary
- Participants engaged enthusiastically, attempting to provide their insights on QB rankings.
- Many expressed frustration about the repeated pairing of lower-tier quarterbacks.
- Others highlighted the need for better filters to exclude underperformers.
- The survey generated buzz, showcasing the passion and rivalry between fans of various QBs.
Engagement and Enthusiasm
The initial excitement for the ranking survey can be felt through the comments section as users jumped in to share their thoughts and experiences. One user, TomahawkaChawpa, revealed, “Made about 90 selections and saw a top 5 QB a total of 5 times,” illustrating the odd difficulty of spotting elite quarterbacks like Mahomes or Allen in the mix. It seems the randomness of the selection process left many enthusiasts feeling a bit disillusioned as they were pitted against less celebrated players like Desmond Ridder and Tommy Devito. The blend of excitement to have their opinions heard and exasperation at the pairing process made for an entertaining read.
Frustration with Pairings
While some users were keen on participating, the recurring complaint was about the quality of the quarterback pairings. Users like Woolly_Mattmoth emphasized the need for a “minimum games started filter” to ensure that the rankings produced meaningful comparisons. The comment section overflowed with sentiments like, “Spent 5 minutes on this with almost every question asking about guys like Zappe, DTR, Rattler, Brandon Allen etc. and just gave up.” This suggests that many found the survey tedious rather than fun, leading to a drop in enthusiasm for further participation.
Ranking Controversies
As the survey continued to unfold, it became apparent that certain players sparked ongoing debates among NFL fans. User CalgaryChris77 hilariously noted, “I wish you could skip one, sorry my opinions on Mac Jones vs. Drew Lock aren’t that strong,” encapsulating the frustration felt towards having to choose between quarterbacks they felt weren’t deserving of comparison. Similarly, byniri_returns stirred interest by asking, “Super curious to see where Herbert ranks in this,” hinting at the divided opinions among fans regarding Justin Herbert’s status as a top-five QB. Such comments exemplified the high stakes that come with QB rankings and how personal preferences dictated many users’ engagement with the survey.
The Fun of Debates
This survey not only served as a ranking tool but also as a catalyst for spirited debate among fans. Fan philosophies clashed as they defended their choices or criticized the tools used for comparison. Genusmk humorously stated, “You’re either a BOLIEVER or a heretic choose wisely bc anything else is blasphemy #GBBN,” emphasizing the tribal nature of QB fandom. Whether it was support for big-name players or underdog stories, the discussions reflected a community united by their love and passion for football. Fans eagerly awaited the eventual results, perhaps hoping for validation of their opinions on their favorite quarterbacks.
As the conversation unfolded around the quarterback rankings, it highlighted just how passionate fans can be about their favorite players. Whether faced with frustrating pairings or diving into intense debates, the essence of football fandom shone through. It’s interesting to see how such discussions can cultivate a sense of community, albeit through shared frustrations and humor. The anticipation for the results is palpable, with everyone waiting to see if the rankings will align with their personal beliefs or shock the community altogether.