Users in a fishing subreddit are puzzled by a fish that resembles a musky but has unique markings.
Summary
- Debate on the fish’s identity: musky, pike, or hybrid
- Users consider regional differences in fish species
- Mentions of chain pickerel, pike, and muskie as potential IDs
- Speculation on possible hybrid nature of the fish
Debate on Fish ID
Users are divided on whether the fish is a musky, pike, or hybrid species. Some suggest it resembles a chain pickerel X northern pike hybrid due to its unique markings, while others argue it could be a pike with faint colorations.
Regional Variation
Regional differences in fish species are brought up, with mentions of European pike having distinct features like black eyes. Some users speculate that the fish might be a hybrid between pike and muskie, common in certain areas.
Size and Markings
Questions about the size of the fish and markings on its tail fins emerge. Opinions vary, with some leaning towards it being a large pickerel or even a largemouth bass, adding to the mystery surrounding its true identity.