Extra Time Podcast Cancelled: What's Next for MLS Media? - SirShanksAlot.com

The ExtraTime podcast is cancelled. After 15 years, hosts Andrew Wiebe, David Gass, and Matt Doyle said goodbye to their dedicated MLS fanbase. This leaves many wondering where to get their Extra Time podcast cancelled fix and what it means for independent MLS coverage. The reaction has been strong, with many longtime listeners expressing their disappointment. Let’s explore why the cancellation of the ExtraTime podcast has hit the MLS community so hard and what the future holds for soccer coverage.

The final pod! Wiebe, Gass and Doyle say goodbye to Extratime after 15 amazing years
byu/Shadowfury0 inMLS

What Happened to ExtraTime?

The ExtraTime podcast has concluded after 15 years, a move that many fans view as detrimental to MLS coverage.
Listeners express gratitude for the podcast but voice concerns about the future of MLS media content.
Fans argue that the podcast was crucial in elevating their engagement with the MLS.
The discontinuation raises questions about the league’s commitment to fan engagement and media coverage.

Key Takeaways

Independent soccer media faces an uncertain future: The end of ExtraTime highlights the growing challenges for independent outlets in a landscape dominated by league-owned content. This raises concerns about the diversity of voices and perspectives available to fans.
Fans crave in-depth analysis and community: ExtraTime provided more than just game summaries; it offered insightful commentary and fostered a sense of community among listeners. This loss underscores the need for platforms that cater to these fan needs.
MLS should rethink its fan engagement strategy: Discontinuing a beloved podcast like ExtraTime seems counterintuitive to growing fan engagement. The league should explore alternative ways to connect with its audience and support the independent media that helps foster a thriving soccer community.

A Look Back at ExtraTime’s Legacy

15 Years of Soccer Commentary

For 15 years, ExtraTime served as a cornerstone of the MLS community. It wasn’t just a podcast; it was a reliable source of information and entertainment for fans. A recent YouTube video discussing the podcast’s end highlights its significance, emphasizing the considerable shift its cancellation represents for independent soccer media in the US. The video underscores ExtraTime’s vital role in providing consistent and dedicated coverage of the league.

The Voices Behind the Mic

Andrew Wiebe, David Gass, and Matt Doyle, the voices behind ExtraTime, became familiar companions for countless fans. Their insightful commentary and distinct personalities resonated with listeners, creating a strong sense of community. The podcast’s official MLS status and impressive 15-year run, as confirmed on Apple Podcasts, speaks volumes about the dedication of both the hosts and their loyal audience.

Connecting with the Fans

ExtraTime’s authenticity set it apart. Fans appreciated the show’s genuine approach to soccer coverage, a refreshing alternative to more polished, corporate-driven sports media. Comments on Reddit praise the show’s insightful analysis and easygoing banter, describing it as essential listening for any serious MLS fan. This genuine connection with the audience made the podcast special and its absence deeply felt.

The Official Announcement and Its Aftermath

While anticipated by some, the official announcement of ExtraTime’s end still disappointed many devoted listeners. The decision, as discussed in the YouTube video mentioned earlier, underscores the growing challenges faced by independent sports media. With league-owned content and exclusive streaming deals dominating the landscape, the future of independent voices remains uncertain, leaving a void in MLS media coverage. This situation raises questions about fan access and the diversity of perspectives in sports commentary. Fans seeking similar in-depth analysis and engaging sports discussions can explore websites like Sir Shanksalot, which offers diverse content ranging from player controversies and team relocations to humorous sports anecdotes and fan reactions, much like the stories we covered on ExtraTime, such as the Judge’s Decision on Ohtani’s 50/50 Ball Auction or the Carlos Alcaraz time violation controversy.

Why Fans Miss ExtraTime

Many fans took to the discussion to express what ExtraTime meant to them personally. One user, Bormsie721, commented, “I know the guys frequent reddit on occasion, so thank you for all the time and effort that went into this over the years.” This gratitude encapsulates a recurring theme in the comments—fans appreciating the hard work and dedication of the hosts who dove into league analysis, team histories, and player interviews. For listeners like Bormsie, ExtraTime was not just another sports podcast, but a reliable source of information that transformed their viewing experience of MLS.

In-Depth MLS Coverage

The void left by ExtraTime is significant. As one commenter on Reddit pointed out, the podcast offered in-depth MLS coverage that’s become increasingly rare. For 15 years, ExtraTime served as a reliable source for match analysis, player interviews, and discussions about the league’s evolution. This dedicated coverage is hard to find, especially now. Fans are left wondering where they can find the same level of detail and insight.

Independent Perspective

Another key aspect of ExtraTime was its independent perspective. While MLS has its own editorial team, which has undeniably increased overall coverage, some argue it limits the space for independent voices. ExtraTime provided a platform for unbiased commentary and analysis, a different viewpoint from the official league narrative. This independent perspective is something many fans valued and will miss. It allowed for a more balanced and critical understanding of the league, fostering healthy discussions and debates within the MLS community.

Engaging Format and Community

Beyond the content itself, ExtraTime fostered a sense of community. The hosts, with their distinct personalities and genuine enthusiasm, created a welcoming space for fans to connect with each other and the sport. Fans on Reddit have praised the hosts’ ability to balance insightful analysis with a lighthearted approach, making the podcast both informative and entertaining. This engaging format, combined with the hosts’ accessibility and interaction with fans, created a strong sense of community. The loss of ExtraTime represents not just the end of a show, but the disruption of a vibrant community hub for MLS fans.

Did MLS Drop the Ball on ExtraTime?

The discontinuation of ExtraTime was met with bewilderment, as many fans pondered why MLS would choose to cut a podcast that provided consistent engagement with the league. Mandolin08 expressed frustration, stating, “It was the only thing MLS produced specifically designed to engage fans between matchdays, which you NEED to develop a league.” This points to a broader concern among fans that the league is missing a vital opportunity to foster a deeper connection with its audience. With the podcast serving as a bridge between match days, its removal creates an information void, making it harder for fans to stay connected with their favorite players and teams.

Centralization of MLS Media Under Apple TV

The shift of MLS media under the Apple TV deal has undeniably altered the landscape of soccer coverage. This centralization potentially limits the space for independent voices like ExtraTime, impacting the variety of perspectives available to fans (Source). While the deal offers a streamlined viewing experience, it also raises concerns about the depth and diversity of analysis. With official MLS content funneled through one platform, the potential for nuanced and critical commentary from independent sources diminishes. This begs the question: does a single, unified voice truly serve the diverse interests of the MLS fanbase?

Impact on Independent Soccer Media

The discontinuation of ExtraTime isn’t just about the loss of a single podcast; it reflects a larger trend. The current media landscape, increasingly dominated by league-owned content and exclusive streaming agreements, puts independent sports media in a precarious position (Source). The absence of ExtraTime, a long-standing, respected show, could have a ripple effect, impacting fan engagement and the overall quality of MLS coverage. Independent outlets often provide alternative viewpoints, in-depth analysis, and a strong connection to the fan community that official channels may miss. Their struggle to survive in this evolving media ecosystem is a valid concern for fans who value diverse, independent perspectives.

Missed Opportunities for Fan Engagement

Ending ExtraTime raises questions about MLS’s overall approach to fan engagement. The podcast was a unique platform that connected with listeners between match days, fostering a sense of community and providing consistent content (Source). Its cancellation leaves a void, especially for those who relied on it for in-depth analysis and discussions. This move seems to contradict the league’s stated goals of expanding its reach and engaging a wider audience. How can the MLS effectively connect with fans beyond game day without platforms like ExtraTime? Perhaps revisiting this decision and exploring alternative avenues for fan engagement would be beneficial for the league.

The Curious Case of the Missing Spanish-Language Podcast

One glaring omission in the current MLS media landscape is the lack of a dedicated Spanish-language podcast. This represents a significant missed opportunity to engage with a large and passionate segment of the fanbase (Source). While the league offers some Spanish-language content, the absence of a dedicated podcast like ExtraTime suggests a lack of understanding of this audience’s needs. Building a strong connection with Spanish-speaking fans requires dedicated content that resonates with their culture and language, not just translated game summaries. Investing in such content is not just about inclusivity; it’s a strategic move to grow the fanbase and strengthen the league’s overall appeal. Supporting independent media outlets could help fill this gap and create a more diverse and engaging media ecosystem (Source).

Fans React to the ExtraTime Cancellation

The overwhelming sentiment in the comments reflected a mix of outrage and confusion. Scratchbuttdontsniff simply asked, “…but why?” illustrating a sentiment that is echoed throughout the thread. Fans are left scratching their heads, in disbelief that a podcast with a dedicated following could be axed in favor of less impactful content. Fcdemergency further articulated the concern, noting that they relied on ExtraTime to keep up with the MLS, saying, “ExtraTime is exactly how I find out what’s going on in the MLS.” The decision clearly sends a wave of uncertainty about where fans will turn for trustworthy coverage and analysis of a sport that is growing in popularity.

Social Media Buzz and Reddit Reactions

The discontinuation of the ExtraTime podcast has ignited a flurry of reactions across social media, particularly on Reddit, where fans expressed disappointment and confusion. One user’s simple question, “…but why?” reflects the bewilderment of many who relied on the podcast for consistent engagement with the league. Another fan highlighted ExtraTime’s importance, stating that it was their primary source for MLS news. This underscores the podcast’s vital role in keeping fans informed and connected.

Concerns About MLS’s Media Strategy

The abrupt end of ExtraTime has raised significant concerns regarding MLS’s overall media strategy and commitment to fan engagement. One Reddit user argued that the podcast was the league’s only consistent offering designed to keep fans engaged between matchdays, a crucial element for growing a dedicated fanbase. This cancellation highlights a missed opportunity to cultivate a deeper connection with the audience. The decision raises questions about the league’s priorities and ability to provide meaningful content. As fans grapple with this loss of insightful analysis and commentary, the future of MLS media remains uncertain. Perhaps fans will find other sources, like independent sites such as Sir Shanksalot, which offers articles on a range of sports topics, from fan reactions to player controversies.

What’s Next for Soccer Coverage?

The overarching themes in the post reflect a discontent with how MLS is taking steps to engage with its fan base. Several commenters pointed to the league’s decisions regarding media as something that will ultimately impact fans’ loyalty and engagement. For instance, Brooklyn_MLS argued that the league is alienating its audience by opting to cut engaging content, stating, “How do you expect ppl to love the league as a whole?” This speaks to the worrying trend in professional leagues where corporate decisions overshadow genuine fan engagement. With new media formats gaining traction, many feel that MLS made a significant misstep by reducing content that resonates with current fans and entices new ones.

ExtraTime was not just a podcast; it was a community. It fostered discussions and debates and became a staple in the dietary media needs of fans. Users expressed similar sentiments reflecting their journey with the podcast from childhood to adulthood—like Youngringer, who said, “…this is not one of them. Will always be part of my soccer story.” While many are saddened by the decision, comments on potential future endeavors by the show’s hosts hint at optimism and anticipation, as listeners hope that Wiebe, Gass, and Doyle will find another platform to continue their discussion about the league.

As MLS continues to grow, the voices and content that engage fans become ever more critical. Fans are hoping that this decision helps spark some changes in how MLS approaches fan engagement moving forward. There is a clear demand for quality content that resonates with the fanbase, and the hope is that the league will recognize this need. Walking away from a staple like ExtraTime may be a misguided moment in their league’s growth story, but perhaps it could also be a catalyst for better forms of engagement in the future. Fans are eager for whatever comes next, but they want to ensure that their voices—much like those of Wiebe, Gass, and Doyle—are heard and valued, keeping the spirit of ExtraTime alive in their hearts and discussions.

Where to Find Your Soccer Fix

The end of ExtraTime undeniably leaves a void in MLS coverage. But the beauty of independent media lies in its resilience. While a major player exits the field, this opens space for other voices to emerge and thrive. Where can you turn now for your MLS fix? Exploring independent soccer podcasts and media outlets is more important than ever. These platforms offer diverse perspectives, in-depth analysis, and a passionate community feel, often missing from larger, corporate-driven media. Think of it as a chance to discover hidden gems and connect with the sport on a deeper level.

Alternative Soccer Podcasts

Discovering alternative soccer podcasts can feel like unearthing buried treasure. These smaller outlets often provide unique angles and a stronger connection to the sport, fostering a sense of community among dedicated fans. A recent YouTube video discussing the implications of ExtraTime’s cancellation noted that its end “is a significant event with broad implications for independent soccer media in the US.” This shift underscores the need to support these independent voices to ensure a diverse and thriving soccer media landscape.

Supporting Independent Soccer Media

Supporting independent soccer media isn’t just about finding new podcasts; it’s about investing in the future of soccer coverage. These outlets rely on community support to survive and grow. By subscribing, sharing, and engaging with their content, you contribute to a more diverse and vibrant media ecosystem. The same YouTube video emphasizes this, stating that independent outlets, while facing challenges, are crucial for “maintain[ing] diverse and critical coverage of MLS.” Your support can make a real difference.

A Shout-out to the Little Guys (and How We Cover Sports Differently at SirShanksAlot)

Here at SirShanksAlot, we get the importance of community and connection in sports. We strive to offer a blend of in-depth analysis and lighthearted storytelling, covering everything from heartfelt fan reactions (like this piece on the Oakland A’s) to humorous sports anecdotes (like this one about a lost golf cart). We also cover controversies in the sports world, such as this piece discussing Carlos Alcaraz. We believe that sports are more than just games; they’re stories, controversies, and shared experiences. ExtraTime understood this. They weren’t just a podcast; they were a community hub, fostering discussions and debates, becoming an essential part of fans’ media consumption. We aim to carry on that spirit of community engagement, offering a unique perspective on the sports world, much like our take on Ohtani’s 50/50 ball auction.

The Future of MLS Media

The discontinuation of ExtraTime raises important questions about the future of MLS media. As league-owned content and streaming deals become increasingly dominant, the space for independent voices shrinks. This shift, as discussed in the YouTube video mentioned earlier, highlights the precarious position of independent sports media. The end of ExtraTime, while a loss, could also spark change. Fans are voicing their desire for more engaging content and a stronger connection with the league. Hopefully, MLS will listen and adapt, finding new ways to connect with its audience and support the independent media outlets that contribute so much to the vibrant soccer landscape. The future of MLS media remains to be written, but the fans’ voices, and their demand for quality coverage, will undoubtedly shape what comes next.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why was the ExtraTime podcast discontinued?

While the official reason hasn’t been explicitly stated, the timing coincides with the centralization of MLS media under the Apple TV deal. This shift in the media landscape likely played a role, potentially limiting the space for independent voices like ExtraTime. The changing dynamics of sports media, with league-owned content and exclusive streaming agreements gaining prominence, also contribute to the challenges faced by independent outlets.

Where can I find similar MLS coverage now that ExtraTime is gone?

Exploring independent soccer podcasts and media outlets is a great starting point. These platforms often offer unique perspectives and in-depth analysis you might not find elsewhere. Supporting these outlets is crucial for maintaining a diverse and vibrant soccer media landscape. You can also check out websites like Sir Shanksalot, which offers a variety of sports content, including articles on fan reactions, player controversies, and humorous sports anecdotes.

What made ExtraTime so special for MLS fans?

ExtraTime provided consistent, high-quality coverage of MLS for 15 years. Fans appreciated the hosts’ insightful commentary, genuine enthusiasm, and ability to connect with the audience on a personal level. The podcast fostered a strong sense of community, offering a space for fans to engage with each other and the sport. It also offered an independent perspective, which many valued as an alternative to official league narratives.

What does the end of ExtraTime mean for the future of MLS media?

It raises concerns about the potential dominance of league-owned content and the shrinking space for independent voices. This shift could impact the diversity of perspectives available to fans and limit the potential for critical commentary. However, it also presents an opportunity for new independent outlets to emerge and thrive. Fan engagement will be key in shaping the future of MLS media, and hopefully, the league will listen to its audience and adapt accordingly.

How can I support independent soccer media?

Actively engage with their content by subscribing, sharing, and participating in discussions. This support helps these outlets survive and grow, ensuring a more diverse and vibrant media ecosystem. Consider contributing financially if possible, as many independent platforms rely on community support. By investing in independent media, you’re investing in the future of soccer coverage.

Extra Time Podcast Cancelled: What’s Next for MLS Media?