McDavid wins the Conn Smythe Trophy, sparking debates among hockey fans on his historic performance.
Summary
- McDavid wins Conn Smythe Trophy on a losing team.
- Hockey fans debate McDavid’s performance versus other contenders.
- McDavid’s aura on the ice and playoff stats are highlighted.
- Comparison to other sports on awarding MVP to losing side.
Geotolkien’s Insight
Geotolkien notes Reggie Leach as the only non-goaltender to win on a losing team besides McDavid, who had a historic performance.
PaleGutCK’s Humorous Take
PaleGutCK humorously describes McDavid’s aura on the ice and the intense reactions of opponents, relating it to puck-watching experiences.
LeanMrfuzzles’ Defense of McDavid
LeanMrfuzzles defends McDavid’s win, emphasizing his exceptional playoff performance over goalie contenders.
mmaguy123’s Basketball Reference
mmaguy123 compares the rarity of a player on the losing side winning the trophy in hockey to basketball traditions.
Conclusion
McDavid’s Conn Smythe win has ignited mixed reactions among fans, showcasing the ongoing debate in the hockey community regarding recognizing exceptional individual performances on losing teams.