Shohei Ohtani is reportedly being advised to avoid the 2024 MLB Home Run Derby amidst mixed reactions from fans and players alike. Some feel the event needs to return to its old format, while others see it as a threat to player health and performance.
Summary
- Fans want the old HR Derby format back
- Players view the Derby’s impact on their swings differently
- From a fun event to a competitive challenge
- Preference for Ohtani in real games over the Derby
Fans Call for Old Format
Some fans argue that the HR Derby should revert to its old format to reduce controversy and physical strain on players. They question the rule of pitching before the ball lands and its impact on punishing players for hitting impressive home runs too early.
Players’ Swing Sentiments
While some players like the everyday batting practice feel, others believe the Derby messes with their swings. The transition from a lighthearted event to a fierce competition has led to differing opinions on how the Derby affects player performance and health.
Real Game vs. Derby
Supporters of Ohtani skipping the Derby prioritize seeing him in action during real games rather than a glorified batting practice session. Their preference lies in witnessing Ohtani showcase his skills in competitive plays that matter more than exhibition events.
The MLB Home Run Derby continues to spark debates among fans and players regarding its format, impact on player performance, and relevance in today’s baseball landscape. As the dynamics of the game evolve, so do the sentiments towards traditional events like the Derby.