The question of whether Josh Gibson is the new MLB GOAT has ignited a fiery debate among baseball fans on Reddit. Is he truly deserving of this title? Let’s take a closer look at what the fans had to say.
Summary
- Fans are divided over Gibson’s legacy, with some arguing for his recognition and others dismissing it.
- Some users highlight the historical significance of Gibson’s career in the context of racial segregation in baseball.
- Opinions range from reverence for Gibson’s talent to skepticism about rewriting baseball history.
Fans React
One user pointed out the segregation in baseball that prevented Negro League players like Gibson from showcasing their skills in the MLB, emphasizing the unfair treatment based on skin color.
Another user expressed skepticism with a simple ‘Yeah, no,’ indicating a lack of agreement with the notion of Gibson as the new GOAT.
A Tale of Tragedy
An empathetic fan highlighted the tragedy of Gibson’s life, including his early death, absence from the MLB, and the lack of witnessing Jackie Robinson’s groundbreaking achievement.
Legacy and Recognition
Amidst the debate, fans recognize Gibson’s legend status and acknowledge his competition with other baseball greats who never had a chance to join professional baseball at the time.
The discussion also touched on the sentiment of pandering and historical revisionism, with some users feeling that Gibson’s recognition was unjustified or unnecessary.
In conclusion, the debate over Josh Gibson’s legacy reveals the complexities of honoring players from the Negro League and redefining baseball history. While some fans celebrate Gibson’s talent and historical significance, others raise valid concerns about rewriting the past through selective recognition.