Is Jay Williams the Greatest Duke Player of All Time?

Stephen A. Smith’s controversial statement about Jay Williams sparks debate on Reddit.

Summary

  • Stephen A. Smith’s claim that Jay Williams is the greatest Duke player receives backlash.
  • Reddit users argue for Christian Laettner as the undisputed top Duke player.
  • Some users criticize ESPN and call Stephen A. Smith names.
  • Humorous comments surface about other Duke players like the Plumlees and Quinn Cook.

Debating the Duke GOAT

Stephen A. Smith’s assertion that Jay Williams holds the title of the greatest Duke player of all time has set the Reddit community on fire. While some users offer counterarguments in favor of Williams, the consensus seems to lean heavily toward other legendary Duke players.

The Christian Laettner Camp

One user firmly believes that Christian Laettner is the undisputed best Duke player, stating, ‘The list starts and ends with Christian Laettner.’ This sentiment resonates with multiple commenters who regard Laettner as a Duke basketball icon.

Criticisms of ESPN and Stephen A.

There’s no shortage of criticism directed at Stephen A. Smith and ESPN in response to the claim. Users express frustration with Stephen A.’s statements, with one bluntly calling him an ‘idiot’ and another labeling him a ‘clown.’ The sentiment extends to ESPN, with one user simply calling the network ‘a joke.’

Humorous Twists

Amidst the seriousness of the debate, some users inject humor into the discussion. From referencing the eccentricity of the Plumlee brothers to sarcastically highlighting ‘Quinn Cook erasure,’ these comments add a lighthearted touch to the intense back-and-forth.