In 2007, the Eagles faced the Saints in a game that would be remembered for a controversial play involving Donovan McNabb. The post on Reddit sparked a lively debate among fans. Let’s dive into the drama!
Summary
- Fans were divided on whether the play was luck or skill.
- Some reminisced about McNabb’s career.
- Questions arose on whether the play would stand in today’s NFL.
Divided Opinions
One user commented, “Now that’s Saints luck baby.” It seems some believe the play was more about luck than skill. On the other hand, another user mentioned McNabb’s agility at age 31, implying it was a display of skill rather than pure chance.
Memories of McNabb
Another Redditor humorously summed up the play as, “Donovan McNabb’s career in a nutshell.” This raises the nostalgia for McNabb’s time in the NFL and his memorable moments.
Modern NFL Standards
There was speculation on whether the same play would be allowed in today’s NFL. A user posed the question if the rules had changed since then, indicating curiosity about the evolution of the game.
The Eagles vs. Saints game in 2007 brought forth differing viewpoints from fans. While some saw luck in the fumble recovery for a touchdown, others admired McNabb’s skills. The debate continues on whether such plays would be permitted in today’s NFL. The nostalgia around players like McNabb adds a layer of sentimentality to fans’ discussions, making this game a topic that stirs both passion and reminiscence among football enthusiasts.