C.J. Stroud’s Rookie Success: Sustainable or Overhyped?

Discussing the potential of C.J. Stroud’s rookie success brings up the age-old debate of sustainability versus regression.

Summary

  • Believers acknowledge Stroud’s potential but warn of the NFL’s unpredictability.
  • Skeptics argue that regression is a real possibility, considering the league’s history.
  • The discussion centers on Stroud’s adaptability against evolving defenses.

Belief in Improvement

I’ve been a Stroud believer since he was at OSU but anyone that thinks *any* rookie is only going to improve after his first year hasn’t been paying attention to the NFL for long. I think him improving is definitely more likely but there are countless players that have had a great season and high hopes going forward then fallen off. – Great_Fault_7231

Potential Regression

I’m going to be “that guy” and suggest a Stroud regression is not out of the question. I agree Stroud has a clear path to continue his successful rookie year, but with everyone convinced he takes that next step, it has to be said stranger things happened in the NFL. – Giff95

Adaptability Against Defenses

By no means am I saying he won’t continue to improve, but the great quarterbacks are the ones that can continually evolve to overcome how defenses adapt to them. Time will tell if Stroud can do that. Teams will be more prepared for him this year. Going to be fun to watch! I think he’ll be great. – leflur

It’s easy to forget how electric Tank Dell was last season. Goddamn that little man had a wild ride last season before he got hurt. It cannot be overstated how excited I am to watch Nico, Tank, and Diggs on the field this season. Bless the knees! – SmokeySFW

I sure hope not. – perfect_fitz

Even if Stroud’s play last year is his ceiling, Texas has a great player they can continue to build around. – Guhonda