Best Treadmills According to Reddit: Top Picks & Reviews

by

Want a treadmill that can handle your workouts and your work-from-home life? You’ve come to the right place. This post compiles the best treadmill Reddit recommendations, from budget-friendly picks to top-of-the-line models. We’ll cover key features, maintenance tips, and even the smart vs. non-smart treadmill debate. Ready to find your perfect match? Let’s go.

[deleted by user]
by inrunning

Best Treadmills According to Reddit

  • Consider getting a normal treadmill and adding a desk on top for a sturdy setup.
  • Underdesk treadmills are likely not suitable for running due to weak motors.
  • Users have found creative DIY solutions to combine their regular treadmill with a workspace.

Why Reddit is a Great Resource for Treadmill Reviews

Reddit offers unfiltered, real-world experiences from treadmill owners. It’s a goldmine of honest feedback, helping you avoid marketing hype and make informed decisions. Unlike curated reviews, you get the straight scoop on what works and what doesn’t, directly from people who have logged miles on these machines. Check out this Reddit thread on treadmill experiences for a taste of what I mean. Users share their personal experiences with various brands, such as Peloton, NordicTrack, and Sole, offering valuable insights for potential buyers.

Key Takeaways

  • Prioritize a robust treadmill over an under-desk model for a combined workspace. Look for a quality treadmill with a powerful motor (at least 3.0 CHP) and a spacious deck suitable for running, then add a separate desk designed for treadmill use.
  • Use Reddit for honest treadmill reviews and recommendations. Learn from real-world owner experiences to understand the pros and cons of different models and brands, bypassing marketing hype. This helps you compare features, durability, and value.
  • Focus on essential features and consider buying used for long-term value. Prioritize features like incline/decline options, reliable speed control, and a comfortable deck. A used, high-quality treadmill can be a cost-effective way to get a durable machine without the potential issues of smart technology.

Understanding Your Needs

Before diving into specific recommendations, think about what you really need in a treadmill. This will help you narrow down the options and find the perfect fit for your lifestyle and fitness goals. Just like choosing the right golf club (check out our article on mixing cut shots and topspins for some sports inspiration), selecting a treadmill requires careful consideration of your individual needs.

How Often Will You Use the Treadmill?

A common theme on Reddit is that a long-lasting, reliable treadmill requires a significant investment. Cheaper models are less likely to be durable and may not hold up under frequent use. If you plan on daily use, investing in a higher-quality machine is worthwhile. For occasional use, a more budget-friendly option might suffice. This discussion on durable treadmills offers insights on the relationship between price and longevity. Remember, investing in a good treadmill is like investing in your health – it’s a long-term commitment.

What are your fitness goals?

Are you training for a marathon or looking for a low-impact way to stay active? Different treadmills cater to different needs. Some excel at incline training, while others prioritize speed and responsiveness. This Reddit thread features discussions on various brands, including Peloton, NordicTrack, Sole, Horizon Fitness, and StarTrac, highlighting their popularity and potential reliability. Identifying your fitness goals will help you choose a treadmill that aligns with your training style.

What is your budget?

Treadmills range in price from a few hundred to several thousand dollars. Setting a budget beforehand will help you avoid overspending and focus on models within your price range. This thread discusses the Sole F80, often recommended for its simplicity and durability. Knowing your budget allows for a practical choice without sacrificing quality. Similar to how we discuss budget-friendly sports equipment on SirShanksAlot (like in our Lost Golf Cart story), finding value is key.

Prioritize Quality Over Convenience

Reddit users caution against underdesk treadmills, citing weak motors that may not withstand running speeds. Building a sturdy desk on top of a normal treadmill seems to be a popular workaround for those looking for a dual-function setup.

Motor Power: The Heart of Your Treadmill

A powerful motor (at least 3.0 HP) ensures smooth operation, especially for runners. Look for continuous horsepower (CHP) ratings for a more accurate measure of performance. As one Reddit user pointed out in a discussion about treadmills, a powerful motor and a replaceable running deck are key for longevity. A higher CHP rating means the motor can sustain higher speeds and inclines for longer periods without overheating, crucial for serious runners.

Deck Size and Durability: Your Running Foundation

A spacious and durable deck is essential for a comfortable and safe running experience. Consider a deck large enough for your stride and made of high-quality materials that can withstand heavy use. Many Reddit users emphasize the importance of a large running surface. If you plan to use the treadmill for both running and walking while working, a larger deck provides more stability and flexibility.

Features: Essential vs. Nice-to-Have

Regarding treadmill features, it’s easy to get caught up in extras. Focus on what enhances your workout and work experience, not flashy add-ons. A Reddit thread on treadmill features highlighted that many users prefer external options for fans, speakers, and screens, finding built-in versions often lacking and harder to replace. This allows you to upgrade these components independently as technology improves.

Incline and Decline Options

Incline and decline features let you simulate outdoor terrain, adding variety and engaging different muscle groups. Look for treadmills offering a good range of incline and decline percentages to challenge yourself and keep routines fresh. This is especially helpful for runners who want to mimic hill training.

Speed Control

Easy-to-use speed controls are crucial. Some Redditors mention that while quick-adjust buttons are helpful for intervals, their placement can be awkward. Test the speed controls before purchasing to ensure they’re conveniently located and responsive. This will make your workouts more efficient and enjoyable.

Built-in Screens and Entertainment

While some treadmills offer built-in screens for streaming, consider if you need this. Many users prefer their own tablets or laptops for better viewing. Think about how you’ll use the treadmill while working and whether a built-in screen will help or hinder productivity. A separate device offers more flexibility and is often easier to update.

Heart Rate Monitoring

Heart rate monitoring can be valuable for tracking fitness and staying within your target heart rate zone. Some treadmills have built-in monitors, while others are compatible with external devices like chest straps or smartwatches. Choose the option that best suits your needs and preferences. Accurate heart rate data can help optimize your training and recovery.

My Top Treadmill Picks

Users like FuliginEst have found a balance by using both a Walkingpad R2 Pro for slow running and a traditional treadmill for faster workouts. DIY solutions such as creating a platform to work with a laptop on a regular treadmill have also been suggested by the community.

Budget-Friendly Options (Under $1,000)

Horizon Fitness T101

The Horizon T101 treadmill is a good entry-level option thanks to its affordability and relatively large running deck. However, some Reddit users wish the belt was longer for more comfortable strides. If you’re on a budget and deck space is a priority, this might be a good place to start your treadmill search.

Sole F63

Redditors praise the Sole F63 for its stability, making it a solid option for heavier runners. Downsides include a weak built-in fan and limited Garmin integration. If those features aren’t important to you, the F63 offers a reliable running experience at a reasonable price.

Mid-Range Treadmills ($1,000 – $2,000)

NordicTrack Commercial 1750

The NordicTrack Commercial 1750 is known for its solid build and easy-to-use controls. The iFit programs also get good reviews. However, keep in mind that older models have smaller screens, and newer versions may have a narrower belt. Do your research before committing to a purchase.

ProForm Pro 2000

One Redditor had a good experience with a less expensive ProForm model, using it for slower runs and pairing it with a TV and Firestick. This suggests that if you’re not training for a marathon, a less expensive ProForm could be a practical option. Learn more about treadmill recommendations on Reddit.

High-End Treadmills (Over $2,000)

Landice L7

The Landice L7 has a reputation for durability—one Redditor even called it “built like a tank.” Another user found a used one for $150 on Facebook Marketplace. If you’re looking for a long-term investment and are open to buying used, this could be a winner.

Woodway

Woodway treadmills are considered incredibly durable (one Redditor called them “bulletproof”). The downsides? They’re heavy (around 400 lbs) and expensive, even pre-owned. If ultimate durability is your top priority and you have the budget (and space!), a Woodway might be worth the investment.

TrueForm Runner

While not mentioned in the Reddit discussions I found, the TrueForm Runner is often recommended for serious runners. It’s known for its unique curved design, which encourages a more natural running form.

Commercial-Grade Options for Home Use

Sole Fitness TT8

The Sole Fitness TT8 consistently receives praise for its solid build, quiet operation, long deck, excellent warranty, and simple design. It’s a popular choice for those who want a gym-quality treadmill at home.

Life Fitness T3

The Life Fitness T3 is another commercial-grade option known for its wide tread and durability. If you have the space and the budget, this treadmill can provide a reliable and comfortable running experience for years.

Smart Treadmills vs. Non-Smart Treadmills

Pros and Cons of Smart Treadmills

Smart treadmills offer interactive features and online classes, but Reddit users warn about potential issues. Software updates can cause problems, app support can disappear, and there’s a risk of your treadmill becoming a very expensive paperweight if the software fails.

Pros and Cons of Non-Smart Treadmills

Non-smart treadmills offer simplicity and reliability. Buying a used, high-end model from before smart features became common is a popular strategy on Reddit. This can be a cost-effective way to get a durable machine without the tech headaches.

Why Trustworthy Treadmill Brands Matter

Many users recommend opting for a trusted brand when selecting a treadmill for running and working. Attachable treadmill desks or adjustable attachments offer flexibility for different tasks while maximizing space and budget.

Satans_Salad shares their positive experience with a treadmill desk, highlighting the benefits of having a versatile setup for work and exercise. Big-Anxiety-5467 also showcases a personalized approach with a tall adjustable table for additional workspace while running.

Ultimately, finding the right balance between functionality, durability, and comfort is key for creating an efficient running and working space at home. By exploring different setups and solutions, users can tailor their treadmill experience to suit their needs

Brands Recommended by Reddit Users

Picking a treadmill can feel overwhelming, but Reddit users offer some helpful advice. They’ve logged countless miles on these machines, so their experiences can save you from a treadmill nightmare. Here are some brands that consistently pop up in their discussions:

Sole

Sole treadmills, especially the F80/TT8, get rave reviews for their durability and simple operation. If you want a reliable workhorse that doesn’t require an advanced degree to operate, Sole might be a good fit. The long running surface is a bonus for those of us with a longer stride. One Reddit thread highlights the F80/TT8 as a top contender.

NordicTrack

The NordicTrack 2450 was a surprise hit for some Redditors. The motivating iFit programs seem to be a major selling point, offering interactive workouts that can help you stay engaged. If you enjoy structured training and a bit of virtual coaching, this brand might be for you.

Horizon Fitness

Horizon Fitness has a solid reputation for reliability, which is crucial when investing in equipment you’ll use regularly. While newer models haven’t been discussed extensively on Reddit yet, their history suggests they’re worth a look. This Reddit thread mentions Horizon’s consistent performance.

StarTrac

If you’re working with a tighter budget, used treadmills are a smart option. StarTrac is one brand mentioned in these discussions, known for its robust build, making it a good choice for the second-hand market. This Reddit thread suggests exploring used treadmills, including StarTrac.

Life Fitness

Life Fitness treadmills are praised for their wide tread and durability. You’ll often find them in commercial gyms, a testament to their ability to handle heavy use. Reddit users often recommend Life Fitness for their robust construction.

Landice

One Redditor called their Landice “built like a tank.” They even found a used one for a great price on Facebook Marketplace, proving that bargains exist if you’re willing to search. This thread highlights the durability of Landice treadmills.

Woodway

Woodway treadmills are considered top-of-the-line by some, known for their incredibly durable construction. However, they’re heavy (around 400 lbs) and expensive. This Reddit discussion mentions Woodway’s “bulletproof” design.

Assault Runner

For a minimalist approach, consider the Assault Runner, a manual treadmill. No motor, no electricity, no app—just you powering the belt. It’s a great way to get a challenging workout. This Reddit thread discusses manual treadmills like the Assault Runner.

Rogue Fitness

Rogue Fitness makes high-quality equipment, including treadmills, though they are pricey. If you’re serious about training and have the budget, they’re worth checking out. This Reddit discussion mentions Rogue Fitness as a high-quality option.

Buying New vs. Used

Buying new offers warranties and the latest features, but used treadmills can save you money.

Tips for Buying a Used Treadmill

When buying used, consider high-end models from a few years ago, before smart features became standard. You can often find a durable, non-smart machine for much less. Inspect the belt and deck for wear, and test it before buying if possible. This Reddit thread offers tips on buying used treadmills.

Where to Find Used Treadmills

Look on Facebook Marketplace, local classifieds, or contact gyms or hotels selling older equipment. You might find great deals. This Reddit discussion suggests places to find used treadmills.

Maintenance Tips for Treadmill Longevity

Regular maintenance keeps your treadmill running smoothly.

Regular Cleaning

Wipe down your treadmill after each use to prevent dust and sweat buildup. This keeps it looking good and protects the internal components.

Lubrication

Regular lubrication keeps the belt moving smoothly and prevents damage. Check your owner’s manual for the recommended lubricant and frequency. This Reddit thread emphasizes the importance of regular maintenance.

Belt and Deck Inspection

Regularly inspect the belt and deck for wear. Address any issues quickly to prevent further damage. This Reddit discussion advises paying attention to user reviews and potential issues.

Related Articles

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a treadmill desk actually practical for running and working?

It depends on your setup and work style. A dedicated under-desk treadmill may not be powerful enough for serious running. Many Reddit users suggest a more robust treadmill paired with a sturdy desk placed on top. Consider your work tasks – if you need to type a lot or do detailed work, running simultaneously might be challenging. Walking, however, is often very doable. Think about what works best for your workflow.

What are the most important things to consider when buying a treadmill for both running and walking?

Focus on motor power (at least 3.0 CHP for runners), deck size (longer is better, especially for running), and a solid warranty. Don’t get overly caught up in fancy extras. A good, basic treadmill from a reputable brand will likely serve you better in the long run. Also, think about where you’ll put it – these things can be bulky!

I’m on a budget. Are there any decent treadmills under $1,000?

Yes, but be realistic about your expectations. Less expensive treadmills might not have the same longevity as higher-end models. The Horizon T101 and Sole F63 are often mentioned on Reddit as decent budget-friendly options, but research their limitations before you buy. A used, higher-quality treadmill might also be a good option if you’re willing to hunt for a deal.

Should I get a smart treadmill or a regular one?

Smart treadmills offer interactive features, but many Reddit users have expressed concerns about software glitches, app support disappearing, and the treadmill becoming obsolete if the technology fails. A regular treadmill offers simplicity and reliability. You can always use your own tablet or laptop for entertainment or virtual classes.

What are some good treadmill brands to consider?

Sole, NordicTrack, Horizon Fitness, StarTrac, Life Fitness, Landice, and Woodway are frequently recommended on Reddit. Do some research on each brand to see what fits your needs and budget. Reading reviews from other users can give you valuable insights into the pros and cons of each brand.