In a discussion about all-time Heisman snubs, Reddit users delve into the remarkable seasons of past players who didn’t receive the coveted award but left a lasting impact on the field.
Summary
- Ndamukong Suh’s exceptional season in 2009 highlights the historical bias towards QBs and RBs in Heisman voting.
- Marshall Faulk’s 1992 campaign and other defensive talents like Orlando Pace and Darren McFadden spark debates on deserving winners.
- Reddit users express dissatisfaction with the limited recognition of players outside traditional offensive positions for the Heisman trophy.
- Manti Te’o’s impactful performance in leading Notre Dame to the BCS championship game raises questions about the voting criteria.
Ndamukong Suh: A Defensive Powerhouse
The consensus is clear among users that Ndamukong Suh’s dominance in 2009 deserved more recognition in the Heisman race. Despite a standout season as a defensive force, Suh faced the bias towards offensive players in the voting process.
[…]
Marshall Faulk and Other Contenders
Users highlight Marshall Faulk’s exceptional 1992 season as evidence of the Heisman snubs faced by non-traditional positional players like running backs and defenders. They argue that Faulk’s performance warranted greater acknowledgment but was overlooked in the voting.
[…]
Defensive Stars’ Impact
The discussion extends to defensive standouts like Orlando Pace and Darren McFadden, emphasizing the lack of recognition for defensive excellence in Heisman history. Reddit users express frustration at the voting trend that tends to favor offensive positions, neglecting the defensive prowess showcased by players like Suh, Pace, and McFadden.
[…]
The conversation on Heisman snubs illuminates the ongoing debate surrounding the award’s criteria and the acknowledgment of players from diverse positions. While offensive statistics often dominate the Heisman narrative, the community’s insights shed light on the exceptional talents that have been overlooked in college football’s prestigious award selection process.